• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Subscribe
  • Donate

WyoFile

Indepth News about Wyoming People, Places & Policy. Wyoming news.

  • Latest News
    • Education
    • Energy
    • Legislature
    • Native America
    • Natural Resources
    • People
    • Photo Friday
    • Places
    • Policy
  • Voices
    • Drake’s Take
    • Madden’s Measure
    • Guest Column
    • Studio Wyoming Review
  • Supporters
    • Membership
    • Underwriting
    • Foundations
  • COVID-19
  • Latest News
    • Education
    • Energy
    • Legislature
    • Native America
    • Natural Resources
    • People
    • Photo Friday
    • Places
    • Policy
  • Voices
    • Drake’s Take
    • Madden’s Measure
    • Guest Column
    • Studio Wyoming Review
  • Supporters
    • Membership
    • Underwriting
    • Foundations
  • COVID-19

Wyoming’s pro-coal D.C. Republicans need a lesson in economics

Wyoming’s pro-coal D.C. Republicans need a lesson in economics

Former Blackjewel miners assemble on railroad tracks to block a shipment of coal at the start of a protest in Kentucky. The protest lasted two months and engendered widespread media coverage and public support. (Syndey Boles/Ohio Valley ReSource)

Opinion
January 7, 2020 by Dave Dodson 3 Comments

Tweet
Share568
Pin
Email
568 Shares
Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Last month, Sen. Joe Manchin (D-West Virginia) successfully steered the passage of a provision that provides lifetime healthcare benefits to coal miners, such as those in Kemmerer, whose employers have filed for bankruptcy. Conspicuously missing from the list of supporters of the bipartisan bill were Republicans Liz Cheney, John Barrasso and Mike Enzi — the entirety of Wyoming’s D.C. delegation.

Rep. Cheney objected that protecting the ability of out-of-work miners to pay for healthcare would have the “unintended consequences” of encouraging private companies to behave irresponsibly. By denying an unemployed coal miner the ability to buy insulin for his child, she hopes to send a message to CEOs to never again try the irresponsible stunt of deliberately running out of cash.

Neither  Rep. Cheney or Sen. Enzi had qualms about voting for a tax bill that provided a break for New York hedge fund managers — now costing taxpayers close to $1 billion every year — yet both expressed concern about the implications to U.S. taxpayers of helping a handful of out-of-work coal miners pay for their prescription drugs.

In today’s Washington, one has to wonder: If we lived in a swing state like Wisconsin — which recently received special provisions to support its dairy industry — or perhaps if coal miners could show up to fundraisers with bags full of money, would our delegation still retain such principled free-market concerns about making sure Wyoming families can afford to go to the dentist? 

Fortunately, there are sound conservative economic arguments for federal support of our struggling coal communities. 

While the federal government has no impact on whether we buy our chicken sandwich at Popeyes or Chick-fil-a, the government does play a role in our energy markets. Most industries rise and fall based on changes in consumer demand and competitive dynamics, and in that respect deserve no special treatment. 

But the federal government essentially chooses the winners and losers in the energy sector. Just as the Nixon-era passage of the federal Clean Air Act and the Clean Water Act once created robust markets for Wyoming’s low sulfur coal, recent policy shifts favoring renewables and natural gas have led to coal’s decay.

I learned this economic lesson first-hand in the late 1970s when the federal government abruptly changed the subsidy policy for the sugar beet industry. Without notice the government altered the rules for farmers, leading my dad to go out of business. He auctioned off one harvester, one planter, one forklift at a time. 

Later, when I studied economics at Stanford University, I came to understand as an economist what I observed as a child. 

So, let me explain the economics of the current situation to our pro-coal delegation. 

The economic justification for our energy policy is that the entire nation benefits. As such, the burden of government intervention should not be borne by only a few struggling communities. Wyoming’s Republican leaders need to explain to their colleagues from Massachusetts and Florida that free markets did not leave our communities in Sweetwater and Campbell counties reeling, changes in U.S. energy policy did. 

Policy shifts that disrupt free markets by picking winners and losers must be accompanied by programs that transition the communities adversely affected.

Support civil commentary with a tax-deductible donation today.

This isn’t theoretical economics and the impacts aren’t isolated to two corners of our state. The fiscal impact of coal’s demise will be felt by every Wyoming school that will be starved for funding. It will be felt by the parents who watch as their children leave our state to find good work. It will be obvious to anyone who wants our public lands protected. 

Fiscally conservative Republicans need to understand that they can support an out-of-work Wyoming family struggling to pay for their daughter’s vaccination without disturbing their conservative economic credentials. Allocating a few pennies from taxpayers in New York to help a family in Gillette buy new eyeglasses for their fifth grader is not an “unintended consequence,” but sound economic policy.


Popular Articles:


Wyo senators' cowardice should not be mistaken for loyalty


Wind project doesn’t belong in Laramie Basin


Wyoming GOP embraces Trump’s phony voter fraud claims


Filed Under: Economy, energy, Guest Column, Guest Columns, Health Care, Natural Resources, Opinion

Dave Dodson

About Dave Dodson

David Dodson is a resident of Wyoming and an entrepreneur who has helped create over 20,000 private sector jobs. He is on the faculty of the Stanford Graduate School of Business where he teaches courses on small business and entrepreneurship. He is a frequent guest on Fox Business and a guest for small business issues on CNBC.

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Greg Rierson says

    February 3, 2020 at 1:49 pm

    As one who spent 26 years working in the Tobacco business I not only agree with Mr. Dodson,, like his father i fully understand what it means to be on the losing end of change. A young person working in the coal industry need only drive up on Casper Mountain and look out to the Northeast and they will see wind turbines as far as the eye can see. The planet is about to throw away its coal powered cigarettes before they kill it. I hope it’s not too late !

    • City: Casper
    • State of Residence: Wyoming
    Reply
  2. Paul Cook says

    January 11, 2020 at 1:43 pm

    Keep up the good effort and ‘education’, Dave. Both parties and medias have been corrupted by dark money. The future of Wyoming’s young working and thinking women and men is at stake.

    • City: pinedale
    • State of Residence: Wyoming
    Reply
  3. Duane Short says

    January 11, 2020 at 12:46 pm

    It would be great to clearly identify, by number, and to provide direct access to the Bill in its most current form so readers can comment on it intelligently. Just a suggestion.

    • City: Laramie
    • State of Residence: Wyoming
    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Want to join the discussion? Fantastic, here are the ground rules:
- Identify yourself with full name and city. WyoFile stands behind everything we publish and expects commenters to do the same.
- No personal attacks, profanity, discriminatory language or threats. Keep it clean, civil and on topic.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter

Tweets by @WyoFile

Search WyoFile

Become an Underwriter
Sign Up for Free Weekly Newsletters

Recent Comments

  • Bonnie Bath on Wind project doesn’t belong in Laramie Basin
  • Shawn Penwarden on Wyo senators’ cowardice should not be mistaken for loyalty
  • D A Alexander on Voter ID bill advances in Legislature
  • Gary Hakala on Wyo senators’ cowardice should not be mistaken for loyalty
  • Rob Dickerson on Wind project doesn’t belong in Laramie Basin

Footer

Recent Posts By Date

February 2021
M T W T F S S
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
« Jan    

From The Archives

  • About Us
  • People
  • Careers
  • Freelancing
  • Underwriting
  • How to Republish
  • Subscribe
  • Contact Us

Copyright © 2021 by WyoFile